Blade vs. Mallet: Choosing the Right Putter for You

Blade vs. Mallet: Choosing the Right Putter for You

  • Chapin's Picks
  • 5 Min Read
  • By Chapin William

    When it comes to lowering your score, no club in the bag matters more than the putter. It’s the one you use the most — and often, the one that decides whether your round ends with satisfaction or frustration. Yet, despite its importance, many golfers overlook the subtle differences between putter types.

    In 2025, the choice between a blade putter and a mallet putter remains one of golf’s most personal — and most debated — equipment decisions. Both designs have evolved dramatically, blending tradition and technology in unique ways. So, how do you know which one suits your game? Let’s break it down.

    1. Understanding the Basics

    Before diving into preferences, it’s important to understand what sets the two apart.

    A blade putter is the classic design — slim, elegant, and favored by purists. It’s built for players who rely on feel and touch, offering a more traditional look at address.

    A mallet putter, on the other hand, is larger and more forgiving. With its extended head shape and balanced weighting, it offers greater stability through the stroke — especially for players who struggle with alignment or consistency.

    Both types can roll the ball beautifully, but the way they help you do it differs dramatically.

    2. The Case for the Blade: Precision and Feel

    Blade putters are all about connection. They appeal to golfers who want to feel every inch of the putt — from the softness of contact to the roll off the face.

    Because of their smaller head size and toe-weighted balance, blades tend to suit golfers with an arc-style stroke — where the putter moves slightly inside on the backswing and through the ball on the follow-through.

    Many pros on tour, such as Tiger Woods and Jordan Spieth, have used blade putters for years, relying on their precision and responsiveness under pressure.

    Why golfers love blades:

    • Clean, traditional design with minimal distractions

    • Excellent feedback and distance control

    • Ideal for smooth, rhythmic strokes with natural arc

    Potential drawbacks:

    • Less forgiving on off-center hits

    • Harder to align for some players

    • Demands consistency and confidence

    If you enjoy the artistry of putting — reading breaks, controlling pace, and relying on instinct — a blade might feel like an extension of your hands.

    3. The Case for the Mallet: Stability and Forgiveness

    Mallet putters have transformed dramatically over the past decade. Once bulky and awkward, they’ve evolved into high-performance tools packed with innovation.

    Modern mallets feature multi-material construction, perimeter weighting, and high MOI (Moment of Inertia) designs that resist twisting on mishits. This translates to smoother rolls and more consistent distance, even when you don’t strike the center perfectly.

    Mallets typically suit golfers with a straight-back, straight-through stroke, as their face-balanced design promotes a more neutral swing path.

    Why golfers love mallets:

    • Extremely forgiving and stable

    • Easier alignment with bold sightlines or contrasting colors

    • Great for players who struggle with short putts or yips

    Potential drawbacks:

    • Can feel less “connected” or less tactile

    • Heavier head may affect distance control on long putts

    • Bulkier look isn’t for everyone

    If you prefer confidence over finesse and want to eliminate variables from your putting stroke, the mallet might be your best ally.

    4. How Technology Is Blurring the Line

    The divide between blade and mallet isn’t as sharp as it once was. Modern designs are creating a new middle ground — compact mallets and forgiving blades that blend the best of both worlds.

    For instance, putters like the Scotty Cameron Phantom 5.5, Odyssey Ai One, and TaylorMade Spider Tour combine mallet-style stability with the feel of a blade. These “hybrid” models cater to golfers who want forgiveness without losing feedback.

    Manufacturers are also integrating AI-designed faces, 3D printing, and adjustable weighting systems to fine-tune feel, roll, and sound. The result: choosing a putter is now more about matching stroke type and comfort than sticking to labels.

    5. Finding the Right Fit for Your Stroke

    The easiest way to determine your ideal putter is to assess your stroke type.

    • If your stroke arcs naturally and you prefer a lighter, more responsive feel — go with a blade.

    • If your stroke is straight back and straight through, and you like a steady, balanced motion — choose a mallet.

    Try both on a practice green. Pay attention not only to how you putt, but how you feel. Confidence is the real performance enhancer.

    Many golfers also benefit from a putter fitting, where launch monitors and cameras analyze your path, impact, and alignment. A professional fitter can show you exactly how each design interacts with your stroke and where you gain or lose consistency.

    6. Looks, Confidence, and Personal Preference

    Putting is as much mental as it is mechanical. A putter that looks good to your eye breeds confidence — and confidence makes putts.

    Some players find inspiration in the simplicity of a blade. Others find calm in the stability of a mallet. Both can be incredibly effective when matched with the right mindset.

    In short, there’s no one-size-fits-all choice — only the one that fits you.

    Back to Chapin's Picks

    Leave a comment

    Explore More

    You Might Also Like

    The Best Electric Caddy of 2025

    The Best Electric Caddy of 2025

    By Chapin William

    Read Now
    The Future of Golf Fashion Isn’t Moisture-Wicking
    The Future of Golf Fashion Isn’t Moisture-Wicking

    By Chapin Leatherwood

    The Complete Mental Game Reset

    The Complete Mental Game Reset

    By Chapin William

    Read Now
    The Hidden Physics of Clubface Control
    The Hidden Physics of Clubface Control

    By Chapin William

    How the Pros Train in the Off-Season — Full Breakdown
    How the Pros Train in the Off-Season — Full Breakdown

    By Chapin William

    How to Start a Local Golf Meetup
    How to Start a Local Golf Meetup

    By Chapin William